Discovery Gaming Community
Ending the Capship Issue(and more) - Printable Version

+- Discovery Gaming Community (https://discoverygc.com/forums)
+-- Forum: Rules & Requests (https://discoverygc.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?fid=6)
+--- Forum: Rules (https://discoverygc.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?fid=25)
+--- Thread: Ending the Capship Issue(and more) (/showthread.php?tid=9215)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29


Ending the Capship Issue(and more) - Akumabito - 06-11-2008

' Wrote:Let me make this clear.
A CAP WHORE is not the people who are posting here on these forums.

Wrong, I'm a cap whore because I don't register. Before there was registration I wasn't.

And those enforcing registration are pvp and bomber whores.

And those that rp are rp whores.

And if I love my momma I'm a momma whore I guess.




Ending the Capship Issue(and more) - Reverend Del - 06-11-2008

' Wrote:I'm sorry. Where did you get this 90% figure from?

They are the Guard. At most, the defence council for Outcasts. Mainly for the Omicron-85 system. They have a ZoI over Alpha but their authority ends at the the JH to Alpha. They have no sway over the everyday deals of Outcasts or what ships get sold or made. Especially when the ships are made on Malta.

Okay 90% is probably a guess, but I know most folks concur that the 101st is who makes the law along with the RoS and the BLS who have voiced no complaints over this policy.

Secondly all that the rules state regarding influence is that the 101st are not allowed to restrict access to anything but Omicron-85, for a detailed description of their activities we must go to their faction status, the admin approved document they wrote, and to their recent Faction Status review for consumption by the rest of us, which they posted a couple of months back. Now we can see that in the status review the 101st did start their policy of restricting capital class vessels, all of them. I see not one dissenting voice to that claim. They actually toned it down when they reposted their faction status after the community had commented on it. Still no dissenting voices. So this is all coming to light now nearly two months after it had been declared all well and good?

Refs:

101st faction status review

101st Faction Status

Finally I can agree with Adamantine. I'm tired and probably taking this thing a little too seriously. Akumabito I ask that you step back and really think about what it is this registration represents.

It's one of three things.

1) A solid attempt to get RP going with capital ships

2) A misguided and possibly futile attempt to get RP going with capital ships

3) A conspiracy by the factions to kill off all indies so we can have all the power.


Ending the Capship Issue(and more) - n00bl3t - 06-11-2008

' Wrote:They've been accepted as that by 90% of the Outcast population.

<strike>I noticed you've edited your post. Is there a response to where you got that statistic from?</strike>

This has been edited as you have responded.

' Wrote:I'm afraid that they represent the Outcast Navy, and as such are quite influential. As to what ships get sold or made... have you seen those bar rumours, you know, the ones where it is stated that they build the dreads on Corsica?

Anyways, being the main part of the Maltese Naval Forces, one would think that they have sway over all production of capital class vessels.
Now, if you're RPing well enough, then I support you in your decision to use a capship. I feel that registration should be there to aid in RP. Also, it seems we've needlessly polarized. Registering shouldn't be too difficult if you ARE RPing correctly, and the entire point is to enable more co-operation and RP between indies and established factions. THAT'S what I want to see here. Co-operation. We don't need to get all uppity about factions vs. indies. We need more co-operation. I would suggest that you at least talk to the 101st, if not register. If you were go up to them and tell the what your RP was, in PMs even, then that would be nice. You needn't say "OK, we'll do everything you say." You merely need RP in a mature and responsible manner. That's what this whole issue started as, and I think that it's been blown out of proportion, by factioners and indies alike. Indies are being too defensive and several seem to be refusing anything a factioner even suggests. Some factioners seem to be acting overly aggressive and confrontational, instead of opening private channels of communication with the indies. I think that everyone's extreme attitudes seem to have exacerbated the problem. Now, why don't we all calm down. Both sides need to be willing to initiate communication, as well, not just the indies.

Would love to see alot more co-operation. Perhaps a little helping advice from the veterans of this community rather than more Ninja Pirate Jesus'.

The point is I shouldn't have to register. Damn right I'm being defensive. It appears that the 101st may possibly have been infected by the Keepers they associate with and are posing a threat to the Maltese people.


Ending the Capship Issue(and more) - n00bl3t - 06-11-2008

]
Wrong, I'm a cap whore because I don't register. Before there was registration I wasn't.

And those enforcing registration are pvp and bomber whores.

And those that rp are rp whores.

And if I love my momma I'm a momma whore I guess.
[/quote]

How are they bomber whores? I mean seriously how can they be? It's not like it's OORP for people to say "//stop talking OORP in system and take it to private" is it? Whereby one person commits an OORP actions in order to stop an OORP actions. It's perfectly in RP. Oh wait...people don't like people saying "//stop talking OORP in system and take it to private" do they?

I don't want to know anything about your family. Whatsoever.:P

[quote= Wrote:
Okay 90% is probably a guess, but I know most folks concur that the 101st is who makes the law along with the RoS and the BLS who have voiced no complaints over this policy.

Secondly all that the rules state regarding influence is that the 101st are not allowed to restrict access to anything but Omicron-85, for a detailed description of their activities we must go to their faction status, the admin approved document they wrote, and to their recent Faction Status review for consumption by the rest of us, which they posted a couple of months back. Now we can see that in the status review the 101st did start their policy of restricting capital class vessels, all of them. I see not one dissenting voice to that claim. They actually toned it down when they reposted their faction status after the community had commented on it. Still no dissenting voices. So this is all coming to light now nearly two months after it had been declared all well and good?

Refs:

101st faction status review

101st Faction Status

Finally I can agree with Adamantine. I'm tired and probably taking this thing a little too seriously. Akumabito I ask that you step back and really think about what it is this registration represents.

It's one of three things.

1) A solid attempt to get RP going with capital ships

2) A misguided and possibly futile attempt to get RP going with capital ships

3) A conspiracy by the factions to kill off all indies so we can have all the power.

I vote 2. It was probably in a hidden thread which didn't see the light of day.

(Part of the Faction conspiracy.:P(This is joke.) )


Ending the Capship Issue(and more) - Akumabito - 06-11-2008

' Wrote:3) A conspiracy by the factions to kill off all indies so we can have all the power.


You don't get as much power by killing people off as you get by forcing people to do things they wouldn't otherwise do.

Again, can you show why this is needed (and not like eppy did, by whining you got killed 4 to one when the 101st itself does the same thing), show how this will help (when these registration posts have little to no RP and no way to enforce RP on the server), and show why it shouldn't be taken as a power play? (when that's exactly what it looks like)


Ending the Capship Issue(and more) - Reverend Del - 06-11-2008

' Wrote:You don't get as much power by killing people off as you get by forcing people to do things they wouldn't otherwise do.

Again, can you show why this is needed (and not like eppy did, by whining you got killed 4 to one when the 101st itself does the same thing), show how this will help (when these registration posts have little to no RP and no way to enforce RP on the server), and show why it shouldn't be taken as a power play? (when that's exactly what it looks like)

You really believe that don't you. I'm an option 2 kinda guy, I personally think that in order for this to work in anyway as it's intended, it would have to be pushed to it's logical conclusion, the forcing of -all- ships to have written RP and that's plainly absurd. I for one would cry out against that. Some folks just don't have the time to crank out page after page of RP. Besides as mwerte likes to say ingame RP > forum RP and he's so damned right.

But capship registration isn't a tool for the conquest of all indys, it's supposed to get folks to have a minimum RP for their capships, the same as is frankly expected of any ship. It's just it's easier to spot an OORP capship because they are so damned big and obvious.


Ending the Capship Issue(and more) - Dusty Lens - 06-11-2008

People keep saying that this is a powerplay/some other terrible thing... But I fail to see what power anyone is garnering for themselves by requesting that a fellow makes the time to document his ship of the line, their crew and their mission. Like Del says, no one's screaming for 10 pages of Hemmingway!

Admittedly I'm not a cap pilot myself, ironically for many of the same reasons that people are now requesting a registry of vessels. It was simply more of an RP investment than I had reason to make at the time. Throwing together a fictional crew, mission and so on seemed like a heck of a chore if I was lacking the inspiration to back it up.

However, it's for those same reasons that caps were originally nerfed: Because people abused them. The registration being proposed by the Corsairs, Outcasts and now Bretonia is a step in restoring the respectability of these vessels so that they may be restored to their former grandeur. Akumabito you are coming off as determinedly obtuse in arguing that you needn't do a damn thing to carry on with their day, the iconic old man sitting on his porch with shotgun in hand, arguing that no one's gonna come onto your property to meter your water.

But then I suppose I don't understand the anti faction and more than borderline anti-community mindset that's recently become the vogue.


Ending the Capship Issue(and more) - Akumabito - 06-11-2008

The point you missed is that unless the factions can show I have done something wrong they have zero right to demand that I post for their amusement.

Even if I have done something wrong, then their right is to screenie it and report me, just like anyone else.

This is an RP server, if someone is oorp report them, don't target someone who has done nothing wrong instead.

The other issue is that the factions constantly remind us that this is OK because they have the power to do it instead of explaining how this is going to help RP, which naturally makes their motives suspect.

Again, can you show why this is needed (and not like eppy did, by whining you got killed 4 to one when the 101st itself does the same thing), show how this will help (when these registration posts have little to no RP and no way to enforce RP on the server), and show why it shouldn't be taken as a power play? (when that's exactly what it looks like)


Ending the Capship Issue(and more) - stone - 06-11-2008

' Wrote:I find the rule's very simple. I have 9 ship's from a L fighter on up to a BS. Sometime's i like a fast L fighter, sometime's i like to just sit around in MY BS and RP.No ship class is harder or easier to fly/RP. It is a matter of choice.
Now as for faction's, and Indie's. I have been in several faction's, was even second in command of 1. I prefer to be Indie myself, as it offer's more freedom of choice.mostly because i hate having someone tell me i must travel 4 system's to help in a fight i did not start, and waste an hour of my free time doing something i may not enjoy. Also joining a group of 6+ ship's trying to kill 1 person(i was the victom of a BS/2 cruiser's/2GB's and several fighter's chase and kill my 1 cruiser just today. Not on my list of fun thing's to do).
Now a having a faction tell me i cannot go somewhere in my indie ship, with same ID/TAG/SHIP as him because i am not in HIS faction is total power whoring,and not right. I even asked an admin about this with a specific example, and was told and i quote "if you are in RP with all proper tag's/ID's/ship/weapon's, and it is not a guard system under ownership you have the same right's to be there as they do. If fired on SS and send to sanction thread" SO all you power monger's, do not push indie's in RP around if it is not YOUR guard system. They have same right's as you.
My biggest example of this is LSF/SA/LNS telling a liberty navy ship with navy TAG/ID he cannot enter Alaska space. WRONG. It is not a faction owned system,it is not a guard system. They are on same side as you, and have same right's as you.
All i am trying to say is as long as a person INDIE/FACTION has correct ship/tag/ID and is RP'n it same as you, let them be.Let them enjoy the game like you. After all he is still on your side whether he has a {}[]-0-
infront of his name or not.
Faction's have there place in Disco, but so do the Indie's.
CAN"T WE ALL JUST GET ALONG?:laugh::):lol:


' Wrote:Now a having a faction tell me i cannot go somewhere in my indie ship, with same ID/TAG/SHIP as him because i am not in HIS faction is total power whoring,and not right. I even asked an admin about this with a specific example, and was told and i quote "if you are in RP with all proper tag's/ID's/ship/weapon's, and it is not a guard system under ownership you have the same right's to be there as they do. If fired on SS and send to sanction thread"

I just wanted to repost this, as it seams to have gone unnoticed.


Ending the Capship Issue(and more) - Akumabito - 06-11-2008

' Wrote:I just wanted to repost this, as it seams to have gone unnoticed.

It hasn't gone unnoticed, it's that the factions think they own you even if you don't join them. They have no respect for indies.