+- Discovery Gaming Community (https://discoverygc.com/forums)
+-- Forum: Role-Playing (https://discoverygc.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?fid=9)
+--- Forum: Official Player Factions (https://discoverygc.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?fid=60)
+---- Forum: Edge Worlds (https://discoverygc.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?fid=72)
+----- Forum: [TBH] (https://discoverygc.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?fid=78)
+----- Thread: Brotherhood Feedback (/showthread.php?tid=10942)
RE: Brotherhood Feedback - Toaster - 01-21-2023
Just a few quick cents from someone uninvolved and uninvested.
The whole point, @"Darkstar_Spectre", is that canonically Kusari and Corsairs are not allies, but that they are trying to become allies. (Kusari and Corsairs wanting be allies is silly but also an entirely different matter.)
While FR1 does seem to be a bit of an issue here, I find that nipping this little conflict in the bud would ruin an interesting opportunity. Corsair factions feuding amongst each other seems like a very Corsair thing to do to me. I would also not be the least bit surprised if this New Corsair Order (or whatever they're called) was created specifically in response to TBH's and DTR's attempts towards diplomacy with Kusari, and that feuding with them is exactly what they are after.
I'd let this play out a bit further and if the New Order or other affected indies take issue, they can go ahead and cite FR1 themselves.
RE: Brotherhood Feedback - AuruemSaber - 01-21-2023
(01-21-2023, 10:05 AM)Toaster Wrote: Just a few quick cents from someone uninvolved and uninvested.
The whole point, @"Darkstar_Spectre", is that canonically Kusari and Corsairs are not allies, but that they are trying to become allies. (Kusari and Corsairs wanting be allies is silly but also an entirely different matter.)
While FR1 does seem to be a bit of an issue here, I find that nipping this little conflict in the bud would ruin an interesting opportunity. Corsair factions feuding amongst each other seems like a very Corsair thing to do to me. I would also not be the least bit surprised if this New Corsair Order (or whatever they're called) was created specifically in response to TBH's and DTR's attempts towards diplomacy with Kusari, and that feuding with them is exactly what they are after.
I'd let this play out a bit further and if the New Order or other affected indies take issue, they can go ahead and cite FR1 themselves.
Normally I wouldn't be jumping to do this, but considering the fact that this isn't the first time I've seen TBH do something like this against an indie or non-OFL sairs, I really do have to ask in this case.
quick edit: since I just remembered somehthing
Back when the funny LR- vs [R]- little war happened neither side actively attempted to have the other blocked from rogue bases, so even if the NWO NCO wants to follow this line of roleplay I don't see why we would need to allow this to manifest into what could potentially be a very slippery slope.
RE: Brotherhood Feedback - SnakThree - 01-21-2023
As long as it doesn't end with FR5, it should be fine. You should not be able to FR5 someone for shooting at hostile things based on ID rephacks.
RE: Brotherhood Feedback - Lemon - 01-21-2023
(01-21-2023, 11:29 AM)SnakThree Wrote: As long as it doesn't end with FR5, it should be fine. You should not be able to FR5 someone for shooting at hostile things based on ID rephacks.
This. What seems to be the issue, they did not want to wreck negotiations with Kusari. DTR and [TBH] are free to RP whatever they want. Let's not confuse RP with actual consequences like FR5s, Solar docking rights, rephack, ID wording (and law changes for factions with law enforcement ID lines) changes.
It reminds me of the 46th RP against my Navy char for following canon characters' orders to the letter against a hostile faction - you can RP all you want, but if it doesn't make sense in canon your FR5s have no chance of being processed. Especially if they'd attempt to FR5 them to the entire NPC faction for attacking a hostile base in this case. The RP was clearly to save face in front of Ku Gov.
RE: Brotherhood Feedback - The Brotherhood - 11-22-2024
Updated the Brotherhood Recruitment thread to something a little more immersive and helpful for interested players.
RE: Brotherhood Feedback - The Brotherhood - 01-26-2025
Over the last 3 days we did a complete overhaul of the Faction Status, because the old one was severely outdated. Lore completely rewritten (just rewording and adding to it), new layout, updated all outdated data, and new visuals to accompany it all. On the technical side we're including a new rank progression system that functions like a skill tree where members can unlock perks.
This was sort of a magnum opus of mine, I've put an ungodly amount of hours into this. Any feedback is very welcome, and I hope you all enjoy reading (or at least skimming through) it!
-Madvillain
RE: Brotherhood Feedback - Fab - 01-26-2025
nice work on the rewrite, feels much better. congrats!
RE: Brotherhood Feedback - Chxlls - 01-26-2025
New writeup looks amazing, and is very simple to follow. Visuals are quality and the writing is sound. Look forward to seeing more of you all.
RE: Brotherhood Feedback - Sombs - 01-26-2025
The new write-up is absolutely outstanding. Very cool both on a visual as well informative level. My only gripe is the claim of ownership over Corsair NPC ships. You are part of the NPC faction, not the other way around.
RE: Brotherhood Feedback - Doc Holliday - 01-26-2025
That faction write-up is stellar. Great job on that.