+- Discovery Gaming Community (https://discoverygc.com/forums)
+-- Forum: Rules & Requests (https://discoverygc.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?fid=6)
+--- Forum: Player Requests (https://discoverygc.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?fid=244)
+---- Forum: Official Faction Requests (https://discoverygc.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?fid=245)
+----- Forum: Official Faction Creation Requests (https://discoverygc.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?fid=134)
+------ Forum: Approved Faction Creation Requests (https://discoverygc.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?fid=136)
+------ Thread: 5th Fleet (/showthread.php?tid=124864)
RE: 5th Fleet - 5th Fleet - 03-27-2015
(03-27-2015, 04:12 PM)SpaceTime Wrote:Your question is right. Well as i said about it above we are curently working on it and as soon as a forum ready version is finished you'll be informed here.What I mean is that a faction seeks officiality either to fill an empty spot in a NPC faction which is not officially represented or to offer something different than the current official faction(s) of that NPC faction. However, at the moment, your RP is somewhat identical to what [LN] already offers, if not much more limited in terms of variation.
And thanks for the feedback.
RE: 5th Fleet - Teerin - 03-28-2015
(01-18-2015, 11:20 PM)Lythrilux Wrote: [...]
Better recruitment might be a good idea also. Not [LN]-tier but your easiness is questionable.
You might want to specify your diplo a bit more rather than more or less going off the back of [LN]'s diplo.
Your goals are also phrased a bit oddly.
You lack a code of conduct but I guess that might not be necessary.
You also need a ZoI.
Basically this from Lyth. To my knowledge, most official factions have at least some vigorous questions in their recruitment, and actually deny some applicants. As for the diplomacy, goals, and ranks - they're really short and some seem poorly worded. Listing a ZoI and Code of Conduct isn't strictly necessary, but they're important to have as well.
You've overlooked these and that's a pretty big deal ... while you're a good group, that in combination with what Pancakes and SpaceTime wrote (plus the fact that you haven't really worked out what to do with that yet) warrants the question as to whether 5th has the qualities necessary and/or expected of an official faction. I really don't mean to sound harsh here, and I've gotten along well with your leader for some time, but 5th has a long way to go. I'll poke back Jack on Skype, though, and we can talk more in-depth about his new idea there.
Also, you misunderstood what I meant. Your motto is great!
RE: 5th Fleet - Charos - 03-28-2015
I've had several encounters with you as [HF] and I can only say positive things about you, ignoring some minor incidents.
RE: 5th Fleet - Dimon - 03-29-2015
I had RP with one of your member - 5th|Max.Fox, he RP'd fine but another one 5th appeared and just:
http://i.imgur.com/W12Wo1c.png
Best RP I have ever had from 5th, to be honest.
You have some good members, at all. Just keep your recruits and everything will be fine.
RE: 5th Fleet - Maxi_Fox - 03-29-2015
was my fault i don't reply to him in group chat and he think i was under attack
RE: 5th Fleet - Yber - 03-29-2015
You seem to refuse to do what a navy is supposed to.
You ignore a "terrorist" in front of Manhattan.
You ignore an outcast next to Manhattan.
You ignore a Royal Navy IFF'd lynx.
Not only that, you also refuse to talk (not just fight against/ take prisoner/ whatever) to the guy and you go do your own thing with people with nomad guns and shells.
You claim to act with fairness and use snubs, but you logged a cau VIII solaris gunboat to chase around a xeno eagle.
You're not a navy faction since you don't act as such, and you don't deserve to go official.
RE: 5th Fleet - Swifty - 03-29-2015
(03-29-2015, 02:59 PM)Yber Wrote: You seem to refuse to do what a navy is supposed to.
You ignore a "terrorist" in front of Manhattan.
You ignore an outcast next to Manhattan.
You ignore a Royal Navy IFF'd lynx.
Not only that, you also refuse to talk (not just fight against/ take prisoner/ whatever) to the guy and you go do your own thing with people with nomad guns and shells.
You claim to act with fairness and use snubs, but you logged a cau VIII solaris gunboat to chase around a xeno eagle.
You're not a navy faction since you don't act as such, and you don't deserve to go official.
Basically this, i can't say i'm happy with 5th encounters at all. Sorry but you can't make it to the top over night, you need to make sense for that and *work* for that.
RE: 5th Fleet - Ryummel - 03-29-2015
(03-29-2015, 02:59 PM)Yber Wrote: You seem to refuse to do what a navy is supposed to.
You ignore a "terrorist" in front of Manhattan.
You ignore an outcast next to Manhattan.
You ignore a Royal Navy IFF'd lynx.
Not only that, you also refuse to talk (not just fight against/ take prisoner/ whatever) to the guy and you go do your own thing with people with nomad guns and shells.
You claim to act with fairness and use snubs, but you logged a cau VIII solaris gunboat to chase around a xeno eagle.
You're not a navy faction since you don't act as such, and you don't deserve to go official.
I thought this was [LN] feedback thread for a moment.
RE: 5th Fleet - 5th Fleet - 03-29-2015
(03-29-2015, 02:59 PM)Yber Wrote: You seem to refuse to do what a navy is supposed to.First of all, thanks for the feedback. Second, I apologize for what happened.. I will handle the issue internally with the player involved, and that the issue won't happen again.
You ignore a "terrorist" in front of Manhattan.
You ignore an outcast next to Manhattan.
You ignore a Royal Navy IFF'd lynx.
Not only that, you also refuse to talk (not just fight against/ take prisoner/ whatever) to the guy and you go do your own thing with people with nomad guns and shells.
You claim to act with fairness and use snubs, but you logged a cau VIII solaris gunboat to chase around a xeno eagle.
You're not a navy faction since you don't act as such, and you don't deserve to go official.
RE: 5th Fleet - Sarawr!? - 03-29-2015
So look,
I want you guys to get officialdom, I think it's great that you're out and about and that your faction activity rivals that of the [LN], it's awesome, I usually love to fly with you guys, but today I'm kind of displeased.
Fighting a losing fight isn't fun I know that, I've lost plenty of fights myself. Losing multiple faction ships to an enemy who you outnumber can be frustrating, it can be infuriating even, and it can definitely be embarrassing, but it happens sometimes, and it's something that you're going to have to realize.
Knowing when to retreat is an important thing, and that brings me to my complaint. Today, when I was logged on my [LN] gunboat and providing a watch over an ongoing fight that your guys (and some [LN] guys too) were involved in and losing, I suggested a retreat and I was promptly freaked out on by one of your members who promptly tried to botfeed from my gunboat, despite you know...the recent changes regarding bots and stuff, in order to avoid losing.
If you're not going to retreat from a lost fight, at least lose with dignity. This is a game, it is okay to lose.