The Black Ravens - Feedback

[Vredes]

I repeat myself. I meant restart the QCP Faction. Not restart as an indie.

It is up to them to decide.

[Havok]

I repeat myself. I meant restart the QCP Faction. Not restart as an indie.

It is up to them to decide.

That it is indeed.

---

Here we are, don’t turn away now – we are the warriors that built this town.
The Discovery Database for Beginners - The Beginners Guide to Discovery - My Feedback Thread

[The Black Ravens]

Well, now I test ships to Ship List. I think at the nearly 2 days Recruitment thread was created.

---

User was banned for: Alhimik, banned indefinitely for cheating, which just had to be done again?
Time left: (Permanent)

[Oldum]

Sure the QCP and the Exiles are both dead, no doubt about it. Though if you want to play the QCP, why not restart the QCP as a whole and not pick apart of their lore, a part of colonial things, a part of this and that.

B2T: It's nice to see the critisicsm that has been offered received and the faction improve to sorts.

I repeat myself. I meant restart the QCP Faction. Not restart as an indie.

I wonder why everyone wants to revive everything ... IF a company "dies" due to whatever reasons, and loses it's reliability, would you revive it under the exact same name ? I belive not ...

Also, there was an attempr for a merc faction not long ago and maybe the 5th post was "reaver wannabes" or smthing like that ... which at some point gives a nice picture of how some ppl here welcome new ideas or attempts ...

So why a totally new name and a somewhat different group ? Cause probably they don't want to have much in common with the former QCP ... and it's not a bad thing, they can build their own reputation, their own style and all, and they don't have to follow what the former groups were doing ...

Last but not least, this kind of attitude was a reason why I left a few years ago and was debating to come back or not ... but seems like not much has changed around here ... just way less people...

---

| Faction Information || Recruitment || Feedback || Internal Communications || Nightmare on Shetland |
| The Mindoro Massacre |

[Havok]

Sure the QCP and the Exiles are both dead, no doubt about it. Though if you want to play the QCP, why not restart the QCP as a whole and not pick apart of their lore, a part of colonial things, a part of this and that.

B2T: It's nice to see the critisicsm that has been offered received and the faction improve to sorts.

I repeat myself. I meant restart the QCP Faction. Not restart as an indie.

I wonder why everyone wants to revive everything ... IF a company "dies" due to whatever reasons, and loses it's reliability, would you revive it under the exact same name ? I belive not ...

Also, there was an attempr for a merc faction not long ago and maybe the 5th post was "reaver wannabes" or smthing like that ... which at some point gives a nice picture of how some ppl here welcome new ideas or attempts ...

So why a totally new name and a somewhat different group ? Cause probably they don't want to have much in common with the former QCP ... and it's not a bad thing, they can build their own reputation, their own style and all, and they don't have to follow what the former groups were doing ...

Last but not least, this kind of attitude was a reason why I left a few years ago and was debating to come back or not ... but seems like not much has changed around here ... just way less people...

Never said they need to take the QCP| name, though I doubt you even looked that far. Though if they want to create a QCP faction, why not base it off the existing QCP things. I'm all for new Ideas and Factions, good for them to make it happen, though If it's a specific faction they want to create, In my opinion it should be all in the realm/width of that faction, and not taking pieces from other factions as well.

Though your attitude isn't much better either.

---

Here we are, don’t turn away now – we are the warriors that built this town.
The Discovery Database for Beginners - The Beginners Guide to Discovery - My Feedback Thread

[Oldum]

Never said they need to take the QCP| name, though I doubt you even looked that far. Though if they want to create a QCP faction, why not base it off the existing QCP things. I'm all for new Ideas and Factions, good for them to make it happen, though If it's a specific faction they want to create, In my opinion it should be all in the realm/width of that faction, and not taking pieces from other factions as well.

Though your attitude isn't much better either.

As far as I can tell, the ID isn't QCP ID ... Queen Carinas Privateers was the faction name , Bretonian Privateer ID is the point. So I see no real reason ( doesn't matter if they did or did not look for it ) to build from their ruins or their stuff.

Don't get me wrong, but mentioning the faction and the ID as one isn't really right.

Yeah, my attitude to a stalemate kid of way isn't the best, as I tend to notice that it kills of many attempts that could have been good and sucessful.

---

| Faction Information || Recruitment || Feedback || Internal Communications || Nightmare on Shetland |
| The Mindoro Massacre |

[Apollon]

Never said they need to take the QCP| name, though I doubt you even looked that far. Though if they want to create a QCP faction, why not base it off the existing QCP things. I'm all for new Ideas and Factions, good for them to make it happen, though If it's a specific faction they want to create, In my opinion it should be all in the realm/width of that faction, and not taking pieces from other factions as well.

Though your attitude isn't much better either.

As far as I can tell, the ID isn't QCP ID ... Queen Carinas Privateers was the faction name , Bretonian Privateer ID is the point. So I see no real reason ( doesn't matter if they did or did not look for it ) to build from their ruins or their stuff.

Don't get me wrong, but mentioning the faction and the ID as one isn't really right.

Yeah, my attitude to a stalemate kid of way isn't the best, as I tend to notice that it kills of many attempts that could have been good and sucessful.

Actually The Bretonian Privateers are Queen Carina's Privateers, same thing. QCP| is more like the, the official representing faction for this ID and faction.

[Thyrzul]

***** off people. It's much worse to attack and nitpick a group apart than it is to trial & error in creating a group.

+1 If I did understand this right

Factions are dying and you are all acting like old farts criticizing new factions that are trying to revive and bring as much of the old factions back to us and in general life back to disco.

EDIT: I for one am with both hands up for this faction +1 from me.

This is a feedback thread, and the faction is getting feedback. You can either complain about how hostile it might look like or grow a pair, take the feedback, and either try to improve upon it or counter it with reasonable explainations and/or arguements.

I am up for new factions too, if I wouldn't be, I wouldn't care about pointing out the flaws I spotted, because contrary to you I also care about quality, not just the enthusiasm. Enthusiasm is good, but not enough in itself.

I would rather see few people try their best to create faction and log on than to see them pushed away out of this hostile community because they weren't perfect at first try.

Do you really think creating a faction is really that hard? Try to keep one alive and then come back.

---

[SnakThree]

DELETE

---

[Thyrzul]

Trying to keep faction alive is a mistake.

Oh, right. We'll see how long Black Ravens will last then. The leader might think you are right, who knows?

---