Official Faction Spring Cleaning

[Treewyrm]

In which case I'm just going to avoid posting in others' feedback threads then if that goes up. That and there are enough one-time limited experiences here as well, to bring them on and wave around as if its a whole picture is narrow-minded. Common sense.

[bluntpencil2001]

Could we test it with a faction to see how it goes before making it mandatory? Say, QCRF since Unselie seems so eager to do this.

Now that is a brilliant idea! If we start with both the Liberty Rogues and QCRF, that would be grand!

---

[Reverend Del]

In which case I'm just going to avoid posting in others' feedback threads then if that goes up. That and there are enough one-time limited experiences here as well, to bring them on and wave around as if its a whole picture is narrow-minded. Common sense.

I don't quite get who that's aimed at, my suggestion was for anyone purposefully attempting to close a thread by igniting the flamethrower be penalised, a genuine misguided attempt at feedback should not be punished.

Mwerte, Eppy has agreed to have the 101st be our lab rat for this if need be.

Now that is a brilliant idea! If we start with both the Liberty Rogues and QCRF, that would be grand!

Liberty Rogues went up after the Admin's took charge and after the faction requests forum went live. We've had plenty of feedback already but if you feel it'd help then I'll stick my neck on the line.

---

Saint Del is considered a holy healer of diseases of children, but also as a protector of cattle.

[mwerte]

Mwerte, Eppy has agreed to have the 101st be our lab rat for this if need be.

Oops, didn't see that...my bad.

---

[Treewyrm]

I don't quite get who that's aimed at, my suggestion was for anyone purposefully attempting to close a thread by igniting the flamethrower be penalised, a genuine misguided attempt at feedback should not be punished.

It's not aimed at anyone specifically really. Del, just put details in your idea, give it more heavy brain crunching thinking, should work I think, but also understand that I'm quite skeptical about it. Past experience haven't been much constructive, so I can only hope this one somehow will be different. Some flameproof armor that can take hot temperatures.

[Reverend Del]

Edit: You're going to penalize somebody's persona, a Character in-game, for something they said on the forum? It's happened before but IMO it leads to heavy-handed admining and a place where people CANNOT disagree with the admins.

I'd actually suggest a short break from the forums, say 24 hours, no in game punishment, but if temp banning someone from the forums is too much work then a short sharp shock via the sanctions would have to be the way to go. It's not a mtter of disagreeing with the admins in this case, it's a matter of trying to shut down intelligent, adult debate with peurile nonsense and flames. It should not be stood for.

---

Saint Del is considered a holy healer of diseases of children, but also as a protector of cattle.

[Othman]

Would recieving the feedback via using polls eliminate the unwanted excess and stray of attention?

---

On the uncharted lagoons of anguish, I sail with a canoe made of my sins.

[tfmachad]

In theory great

In practice, I don't have time for it

Well, if Dieter allows me I try and can work on the Mandalorians'.

I think it's a great idea AND I have confidence that this will turn out to be a flame fest, but I also think that from the rumble a renewed community can arise.

---

Meet the Kriegers - The story of a family and of two men that shared more than just a name
Fantasmas de la Nube Siniestra
I Mon'Star: The Strange Case of Elizabeth Wallace

[Reverend Del]

Would recieving the feedback via using polls eliminate the unwanted excess and stray of attention?

A poll can be set-up in such a way as to avoid sensitive areas certainly, but those sensitive areas may be what's wrong with the faction, full opinions are needed, to cover all possibilities in a poll would be massive. Polls are not an option for this kind of endeavour.

Well, if Dieter allows me I try and can work on the Mandalorians'.

I think it's a great idea AND I have confidence that this will turn out to be a flame fest, but I also think that from the rumble a renewed community can arise.

I don't think it'll be a flame fest, although I will be bringing a fire extinguisher to any thread I may be perusing just in case. But yes from the ashes as it were.

---

Saint Del is considered a holy healer of diseases of children, but also as a protector of cattle.

[Unseelie]

Lots of polls.
A poll can only as a question....so you would have to be able to give a choice, which means you would already suspect if something were wrong...
What if you just asked for input?
I believe that would be a much broader tool than a poll.

---