Gonna put all my sigs here to get your thoughts on them. First off, I know that "LWB" is misspelled in the large Wesley Richter sig, please don't point that out.
I've always thought that the first 5 looked kinda shoddy... bad choices of fonts, use of bevel/emboss, poor aesthetics, low quality images (Vic Chonody in particular).
The next 3 are great, the three after that... meh.