Posts: 6,887
Threads: 412
Joined: Aug 2007
Staff roles: Story Dev Economy Dev
' Wrote:Jack, if that is the only reason, then do us all a favor and dont post.
If you have nothing constructive to say, don't post.
Otherwise, I say go for it.
Note: I'm not in this faction.
Jeremy, it is valid feedback. If Jack feels the reason the last incarnation of this faction collapsed due to its leadership, and that same leadership is at the helm again, it is food for thought. Similarly, if he feels that the leadership was responsible for creating a largely negative experience for the factions and players it interacted with, he is giving valid feedback.
Speaking out against a player isn't necessarily hate against a player - if the player is considered to be the root of the problem, negative sentiments are inevitable. People shouldn't sugar-coat their (constructive) opinions simply because it might upset someone. I personally would value honesty over someone being nice to me any day.
That said, I wasn't actually here when all this trouble with Murphy started, so I honestly couldn't comment on it. I'll watch and wait to see how this one turns out. I'd hope this time things'll run a lot smoother.
And aren't you supposed to be leading the Mollys, Avalanche? :P