Judcial Order

[Jihadjoe]

1) This statement both feels just clichéd and wrong.

Okay.

Of all people I'd think you would know this.

Not if I disagree with your position, no. I think this stems from you failing to grasp the gist of what I am saying.

Accountability is held by the people, not a House Government with this world.

No... Accountability is not held by the people. The law, police and judicial system are accountable TO the people.

If it was, I would think there would be a much greater effort to keep "Secondary" players using an ID used by a "Primary" in check.

This is impossible. The faction rights embedded within the server rules are a joke and do not allow you to keep independant players "in check". This is something that needs to be addressed. However, considering it is not a roleplay issue but a server rules issue, it is not relevant to the post I made.

After a year, I have seen multiple actions by secondary ships of both house and pirate that do not reflect the RP of the house but claim they are and very rarely do I see a primary group deal with Secondary's when it becomes a problem.

See above.

If they are not being held accountable by their own Primary factions, who are they accountable too? In a RP perspective, if the government they are affiliated with is not dealing with them, then again, how can they claim they are part of it?

See above.

Your statement on the Freelancer ID is news to me. There is nothing on it that says you can only engage to defend yourself or in pursuit of a bounty.

The freelancer ID holds no inherent diplomacy, unlike faction IDs. If I were to make a freelancer ID'd ship and were to fly around saying that I am hostile to X group, and that I would shoot X group, I would be sanctioned within the week for attacking folks without employment to do so.

If you were infact able to just declare whoever you felt like as an enemy and then shoot them, the freelancer ID would pretty much be a terrorist ID, in disco terms. The "Kill whoever you feel like, whenever you feel like it" ID.

You failed to understand my post in all sorts of ways, and as a result answered in a manner which doesn't really follow the line of questioning. I'll try and rephrase it.


1. What do you actually do?

2. You are not tied to any house nor are you a part of their law enforcement/penal/legal institutions. The houses therefore will not allow you to enforce, adjudicate, punish or otherwise act on their law, except in the role of a normal citizen. Do you understand this, and if so, how do you intend on getting around this issue?

3. This faction officiality request does not actually outline what the faction's in game actions are in any way. it waffles on about justice this and blah blah that, but it's all extremely wafty as to what the in-game, in-roleplay function of the faction is. What are your goals, what methods will you use to achieve them?

---