RE: The sanction of the Hess/Bret Combined Forces BattleGroup

[Trogdor]

This is only question of sanction for Bret side. From Hessians it was clear ID violation, no things to talk about:
What do you want to know more? I don´t know what the hell Hessian players thought when they decided to do that. And by the way, I assume that they appered in Cambridge strongly ooRP by Skype of some BAF/BPA/BIS member ("hey, mate, brets are ruining the corsair base in cambridge!"). I doubt that inRP somebody invite them, and I don´t believe that they appeared here just accidently (luckily with some battleships, ehm...). You can try justify it by RP as you want, but ID is clear. Full stop.

Very uneasy question is if and how sanction Bret side. :unsure:
Important part is that RM ID is not forbidding it, ID doesn´t say that they can´t do that. If RM say "from tomorrow all IC ships will be shot on sight" it´s ok by ID and RP. Some consequncies will come but it´s ok. So Hessians are fully guilty. Brets...hard to say how right solve this situation. :unsure: It seems that admins (I doubt that sanction comes only from one admin´s decision) saw unfair to punish only one side...

RP > ID imo. Seems like this is something that should have come down to a judgement call.. It does say don't do this, but I think in this case it should have been allowed. Kinda like how recently there was a guy who was not legally allowed to own a gun, but charges were dropped against him when he shot a home invader.


When the Zoners were attacking the Sairs recently because of the FP9 controversy, were there sanctions? Nothing that says Zoners can do anything offensively. But roleplay led to it being logical so it happened.

---