I say 360. All games are personal with your gamertag, and all games give you scores for different things, achievements, awards, etc. Live is also VERY good, gamertag's are awsome, and xbox has a really good way of working with all of it's games. You can also save movies onto it, music, pictures, etc. I think the PS3 is too complicated, and the 160 has been better from what I have seen so far. Also, the controller feels better than the PS3.