Because, telling people stop their flame wars will ALWAYS work...
Idea is good, but like Tree I'm a little concerned that this will turn into bashing either a faction or a faction's events or a certain person in said faction...
Could we test it with a faction to see how it goes before making it mandatory? Say, QCRF since Unselie seems so eager to do this.
Edit: You're going to penalize somebody's persona, a Character in-game, for something they said on the forum? It's happened before but IMO it leads to heavy-handed admining and a place where people CANNOT disagree with the admins.