To be very blunt, elgato, this is why we don't point out a faction in specific:
If I were to copy over the faction status of X.
Point out 13 mistakes, and then ask that they fix it, the response would be: "you're not a member, you're not helping, stfu."
Were I to persist, it would get much worse, and moreover, alienate me, while I was trying to make a faction stand up and play right.
Yes, that's loaded with personal biases.
Yes, that's gross.
But lets face it.
The fact that this proposal is here is a testament to the fact that some people think that there are certian factions that need work, but are afraid to point out those exact factions. Yes. People are hiding. They don't want to be perceived as a whiner, or whatnot, because they perceive a problem with any specific faction, and they see this as a good way to do that without coming out as the bad guys. Its a way to organize the whole mess, and make it look decent. Elections instead of a bloody revolution, as it were.
As for flames, it will be a lot worse if we're forced to create individual, pointed threads, because the factions at fault will not be the ones that create them.