You need to be careful you are not trying to make factions the way you thing they should be because theres something about that that just doesn't feel right.
Tree has some very valid points .. To me it seems like a few people don't like the way a few factions are run and want a chance to give there views on it .. Fair enough but I don't see why this needs to be in a public domain where all manor of flames will happen .. If your not happy with something to do with factions PM Hoodlum or the faction leader and try and deal with these problems privately.
The idea is a good one in essence but I have a feeling this will just give a place for the whiners and flamers to vent there anger at what they "think" a faction should be run which in turn will leave allot of hard feeling and the community really doesn't need such a thing.
Forcing everyone to comply because you have a problem with a couple is wrong in my opinion.
And im not just saying this because I don't want the factions im in to be re-evaluated because I would put The Brotherhood up in a heart beat and I don't believe RM would have many problems.
But there is allot of hard feelings towards some factions and how they are run, there back story's, the not FL enough and I think this would just get very messy very quick.
And lets remember that everyone has there own opinion on how something should be done, on how a faction on Discovery should be run but yours is not always the right one.