Well, there were only four of us there at the time, you, the {AFC} who we already pirated for AFKing outside of Ames and my guy. If it wasn't you, then it was the AFC guy, whatever. You both are in the faction, so I will just address you as the same, even though you are using untagged characters.
You are a freighter, that is true, but you still can be demanded one of three kinds of demands. Monetary demand- asking money. Cargo demands, which is self-explenatory or roleplay action demands. The later can be either leaving system, doing a barrel roll, forced to say in system chat that Rogues Rule or whatever other.
It is still a demand and declining a demand gives me all right to pop you.
Your demand in particular was:
[20.04.2015 17:50:45] LR-Armchair.Traveller: Yo buddy.
[20.04.2015 17:50:54] LR-Armchair.Traveller: You ever think about joining up with the Rogues?
In other words, I specifically asked you to join my group.
[20.04.2015 17:51:31] LR-Shared.Bride: That was not a question.
[20.04.2015 17:51:33] LR-Shared.Bride: That is a demand.
That sort of piracy is not the norm, so I even went out of my way to state it clearly that it was a Demand. It was to imply what would happen if you refused it.
Flying a freighter with BMs do not really mean a lot for me, because no rogue base sells BMs. It was Junker cargo. We could not care less where it went, because you were obviously not taking it TO a Rogue base. You gain no protection from us in that case.
And obviously I would not tell a HAU 2 freighter to attack something, so instead I was going to make you go scouting and give you money for every trader you spot or any heads up about an approaching navy you gave. That offer, however, we never got a chance to offer you, because you simply stated you were working with the AFC and had no interest in being with us.
We would have done the same with the AFC, if not the fact that we already pirated him.
As for our ID, this is literally every unlawful ID you are describing. It does not change the fact that apart from monetary and cargo related demands, there are also ones which do not involve either. The IDs are already going to be remade due to their poor wording, and since every day there are all three kinds of demands being made, I do not see a reason to apologize for it.