Enforcement of Roleplay Consequences(TM) and cloaks

[Foxglove]

The ID actually states you can attack ANY ship in the ZoI. If we'd go that way, NC and 101st could engage each other freely.

This is false, as more sanctions than just this one I bothered to dig up have shown over the years. Ships bearing the same IDs are not permitted to attack each other, except in the case of FR2 (and possibly some other fringe scenarios I didn't consider)

divine please stop ninjaing me

We are not practicing case law here, Omi. According to the server rules, ID overrides them, and the ID states "any" ship. If there have been sanctions simply because of PvP and not because of external factors like ooRP grouping or dubious ooRP chatter, which is present in the case you mentioned (the other pirate ordering the attack). Point and case, if the sanction were to solely be based on the attack and nothing else, it was wrong back then as is now as well with the current rules.

---