Player Sanctioned: Misfit

[Misfit]

I fired CDs at the destroyer while it was trying to run away from the battleship outside Manhattan. That's fine, that's not an attack nor a sanctionable offence.

This is where you mistaking about 3 things .
1. Firing CD on ship that is already under fire of NPC base/POB/NPC Battleship/Player battleship IS attack , because your actions directly change situation , player you CD cant flee because of your actions and are damaged ( or killed ) because of your actions , therefore CD in situation like that IS attack .
2. To make matters worse , you also breach your ID limitations by firing CD without RP cause and without letting your opponent know you are under contract .
3. And third , you attack without RP to , one message "Interesting" before engaging is NOT attack declaration .

Thats what i tried to explain you in PM , but you refused to hear my point , i hope you learn something , and see you in game .

1. Nowhere in the rules is this regarded as an attack, and I'm yet to find another sanction where a single CD has constituted an attack leading to a rule break. I can understand how it can be interpreted as an intent to attack, but the action itself is not. You were not under fire from anything at this point except the distant Long Island, which wasn't hitting you, just firing in your direction. You were waiting for lawfuls to show up and attack you for a fight.

2. I did not breach my ID by attacking you. I did not attack you, I fired a couple of CDs. I understand that I should have done more roleplay in local chat to show that the battleship and I work together and that I was doing what I was doing because I knew I'd be paid.

3. I didn't attack. No attack declaration necessary. I'm not going to write out five lines of roleplay at someone every time I want to CD them for whatever reason. Nobody is, that's absolutely absurd.

You died because I kept you pinned for the battleship. You weren't aware I was working for the battleship, that's why I'm here having lost money. I have accepted the sanction and I've been punished over this. You don't need to come in here and cry at me about how you were engaged without roleplay and that I broke rules.