Why is this going on? If you are going to argue for two days about it, nothing will get better. Leave him his break. He tried his best to have fun as part of the faction he was and the amount of unenjoyable encounters just took overhand. Telling him he was wrong with on subjective matters that really need more than words to describe the situation truefully won't make anyone have more fun. Highjacking this thread for flood or arguements won't lead anywhere. Everything we can gain from this thread is that everyone should be a bit more considerate when playing in Liberty, as not every LN/5th is only logging for the pews, and that's it.
Does it need 5685943789 more people who weren't involved to state their opinion and join the argument on who was wrong?