I'm not related to this situation in any way, I'm just stating my indifferent opinion on it. A person in question (again, from my point of view) didn't broke any server rules. They were fighting against multiple A/)- tagged ships and the ship they've killed was tagged with the same tag. Doesn't matters if the person was AFKing, but it does matters if it the person in question (The (C~ tagged ship) didn't put any engagement notices against Auxesia ships before the very beginning of the fight. But if they were in the same group, the (C~ guy had the complete right to annihilite the AFKer if they wanted so.
So in the end, it was up to the (C~ guy to decide the AFKer's fate. I can't really see any points in rambling about this situation other than the person behind the character. But the ooRP reasons should stay ooRP.