DiscoveryGC ID Overhaul - Official & Independent [Arioch's Proposal]

[Lafayette]

Firstly, I really don't see how you made the ID easier to understand with that. Secondly, you also arbitrarily tried to add restrictions (shown in spoiler above in red) into our ID that were not there previously, and for good reason. The Vagrants are not diplomatically tied to the Oracles where we would consider them worthy of allying with. We also would be unable to further individual roleplay with mere Freelancers for example, because they are not part of the Oracles, the Commune, or the Wild. It would be best to allow official faction leaders to decide themselves how their IDs are worded, as they know best what is good for the factions they lead.

Firstly, I took up where @Arioch stopped working. Secondly, like him I am seeking out official faction leader feedback like you are providing now (see next paragraph). Regarding your proposal I will check it later.

You can roleplay with Freelancers, why you cannot do it with this now? As for the Oracles, they have been removed.

Regarding this line in freelancer ID:

-Can attack any ship in self-defense or to protect a ship or base of the same affiliation.

I think it's a bit confusing. By reading it I get the idea I can only protect ships with the same affiliation as me (other freelancers only)
My suggestion would be to keep the word "allies"

"Allies" is actually confusing and creates too many loopholes. How would you classify allies to a freelancer? He can be everyone and no one.