DiscoveryGC ID Overhaul - Official & Independent [Arioch's Proposal]

[Karlotta]

Or maybe instead of declaring it to be nonsense, you could think about what I said a bit more.

In every case where there is an exception to something that is forbidden (for example you cant shoot lawfuls but you can shoot unlawfuls), you'll have to express that it's permitted in certain circumstances (here: unlawfuls) too.

And that in cases where there is an exceptions to something that is is permitted (for example you can shoot unlawfuls but you cant shoot lawfuls), you'll have to express that it's forbidden for the exceptions.

There is certainly room for removing redundant things and formulating IDs shorter than the existing ones. But using either only positive or only negative formulations isn't necessarily the best way to describe everything. Although saying only what is forbidden may be shorter in most cases.

Also, IDs give suggestions and ideas to what SHOULD be done, not only say what shouldn't be done, even if that were shorter.

---

User was banned for: https://discoverygc.com/forums/showthrea...tid=200950
Time left: (Permanent)