if the JG has a full schedule contract table, they are doing a good job for a mercenary guild. - that is mostly cause they are also very confidencial and quite. what i like about the JG is that they haven t "pissed" anyone off ( based on their RP ) to be kos ( other than some equipment thingy, which is - from my point of view a rather feeble excuse to kos someone, to question someone - yes... but not to kill or threaten )
from what i gather ( which is not much, i daresay ) they haven t taken up any side ( unlike the AW or the mandalorians ) and publicly announced ther allegiance with the groups. they have been offering their service neutrally and mostly professionally - much like "no matter what past we had, we are now only working on the future ( the near future )"
however - that is what i gather from what i see and hear.. and i do not have much contact with the JG. - when i see them, they are / appear to be just active enough to be present. their traders work OK - and for what its worth - i have no problem with a mercs trading fleet ( i would be positivly surprised if more factions revealed their money sources like that - AND took the risk to live with the consequences )
now, the negative things i gathered:
the JG appears to be - just like the common zoner - rather lost. the only times i see the JG in person is .... tadaaa.... in manhatten orbit. - i know its not really too exiting, but since you are zoner affiliated to a basic extend, i d expect you guys to hang out a little more at the freeports or make patrols.
i don t do it often - but there isn t too much to do anyway - but once in a while, i take my ship and simply pay every existing freeport a visit on a "all around sirius tour" - which is quite funny ( ahh, as a zoner you think looking a a pebble is already funny and dead exciting )
more zonerish diplomacy - more contact with the council maybe would be in order.... but like i said at the beginning. - if you actually DO have contracts running, you appear to fulfil them quite without angering many people, which is.... after all - a positiv thing.
so from a RP point of view - the more contracts you fulfil - and the less we know about it, the better the RP. thats how i sum up the RP of a neutral mercenary group - simple after all.