In my opinion: Bans should be public, everything else should be private. Bans should be transparent so people know why someone is no longer around, but do you need to know NewPlayer56 was warned for not having an ID?
In an ideal world you'd have an automated ticket system so people who posted sanction reports / player requests can actually be updated to the status of their report/request, but I doubt anyone wants to develop anything for MyBB if they can avoid it.
