Well looks like someone missed my point. Yes it should be public, so this way players can see that "crime" doesn't pay! You can simply put that player in bastille and give it a warning, like so many times was posted in the sanctions section. If the players continues to make the same "mistake" then a real punishment can be made. otherwise it gives a feeling of impunity, and that those who follow the rules are not worth reporting, and that so many... why not also not follow the rules?!