Players Sanctioned: Various Corsairs

[John'DTR'Grey]

Good day,

After watching the proves submitted. I believe those rule breaks are invalid and the sanction is not solid. I will argument it all. Let me please disclose it all:

1) DSACE what shows some sketchy chat, and also a normal fight engagement. It's not the first time Phoenix, when pirated, rejects to stop (and they have the absolute right to do so) but when faced by the consequences, one can't complain.

[19.06.2025 21:09:04] DTR-CNS>Edessa: Three Phoenix on scanner
[19.06.2025 21:09:09] /fm gmg 'sair at the jump gate 19
[19.06.2025 21:09:09] (\^/)Thelema: 'sair at the jump gate 19
[19.06.2025 21:09:13] DTR-CNS>Aleksandaros-3: Wepons hot

- I do not know if there is any RP related reason for this totally OORP chat to GMG from Phoenix zoners, not the one here to judge.

2) Phoenix, apparently by the proves, shoot first as shown in the next capture, meaning corsairs are defending themselves and the nature of rule 2.1 ain't broken. After checking other sources, there is the Vizela[TBH] that fires a salvo of gunboat primaries, that really make close to no damage to the bulwark. Then, the Thelema fires a full salvo of the BC gun to the rest, and battle starts. They were running and as we can see, there are many demands to stop, and telling phoenix to go nowhere. There is an active FR3 on phoenix from the Corsairs also, and with the transport changes I am pretty sure bulwarks count as "fairly defensively ships".



The red fire comes from the BC weapon of the other bulwark.

3) Where does the rule break 2.0 comes from? There is no evidence, not even dubious one about any 2.0 argument being broken there. Every ship might have his ID, and the ones not, if there is any. are not specifically listed.

I wish staff to review this sanction, since evidence is unclear, not solid, and the sanction is vague in its nature.

Feel free to contact me in discord for anything,

Salut.