I just read from page 12 to page 16 of this as it was all new posts and I gotta say ... CALM THE HELL DOWN.
While some of the points the others have raised may be valid, it's not like half of the other factions out there don't commit those same TERRIBLE crimes. -.-
It just seems to me like the DW are the medium through which everybody channels their hate towards the folks on the server they don't like. Yes, DW have screw-ups, they screw up more publicly than some other folk. That doesn't mean they're a horrific faction that should be shut down for PvP whoring, not talking ever and being isolationists - mostly because it's untrue.
To sum up, I think you guys are alright as it goes. You need to dot your 'i's and cross your 't's a little more but otherwise, you're alright.