Good VHF pilots know how to avoid coming in, straight line, shields down against a bomber. Dodge for ten seconds till your shields pop up and oh your hard to kill again.
Second, good pilots of gunboats who sit in turret mode, strafe, aim, and have a missile are nearly unbeatable.
And any ship bigger than a gunboat that gets solo-ed is terrible. End of story. You realize that two hits with all of your turrets cause us destruction, and you complain that 2 shots that move 500m/s and use all of our power supply is unfair to kill you? o.0
Granted its hard to hit a target thats tiny, try whittling away 250,000 shield points 3 times (bats) and then 240k hull (x2.5 hull if you have brains) a few times (bots). Honestly I have to shoot through 750k of shields and a million and a half of hull to kill a Liberty Cruiser, that is a lot of hits while dodging fire.
Lastly, sorry, but any capship above a gunboat is simply a weapons platform, very little maneuvering skill involved, simply aiming. Want to fly a ship where the top pilots can beat the odds considerably (ie killing a few fighters and its gunboat escort?), get in a bomber. Craziest ride you'll ever have.
The only problem I see is that caps, even when properly guarded (lets say a GB and 2 VHFS), can still be killed by 2 bombers because its quite hard to shoot down bombers quickly. I think the firepower of VHFs should be slightly increased universally... it'd make little difference in VHF versus VHF fights, but would make VHFs better against bombers.
[font=Comic Sans Ms]I have to agree with Spades. There should be no need to nerf anything. Infact Anti-matter torps are non-guided projectiles, which gives the capital a small chance to dodge it's fire. Besides in the solo-player version, capital ships got destroyed all the time by one tiny little torp, atleast now a crusier has a chance to flee or fight back. As for improving VHF? Nah, as many times I've used a Tidian Bomber, I could never turn fast enough to match any other fighter I faced. You can have the best bomber in the game with rare guns and be a excellent pilot, and still get owned by a VHF (or even HF). Leave things just the way they are, thank you!