Actually Role Playing

[tazuras]

The issue is, this is a cooperative RP environment, where different peoples 'personal RP's' interact, which makes them a little less personal. In disco, there is no dungeon master though, no one assigned to help every new player with their RP and make sure it is sensical, so players take on this responsibility.

I think that everyone should finish RPing a situation before they get into the OORP commentary on another players RP. I myself have not done this in the past but I think I will from now on. Give it a chance, see if it makes sense, and if it doesnt, talk about it later once everyone has had their chance to fully play out their RP. If someone doesnt let you do this, ask them to.

As for your first point about forum commenting, that ones easy, just explain your reasoning in every case, so as to give someone a chance to respond to your specific concerns. And if someone doesnt explain their specific reasoning why they dont like it then be specific about why it would work and ask their opinion on your reasoning.

---