In issues as the above, every concerned person presents their case. When asking for balance to shift, the onus should be on those wanting the balance to shift to them to prove their cases with no reasonable doubt remaining that its best. Those who disagree should present their reasons for doubt. If they can't be overcome, that shows a lack on the presenter's part or else shows there is indeed a reason to reconsider.
Sympathies to the admins--you get the fun part--making the actual decision.