Corsair Order alliance

[Zeltak]

The corsairs gain:
1: The survival of teir species in a war with an alien race
2: Less bounty hunters on their asses. Bounty hunters hunt Corsaires too

In Role-Play I have not seen any information regarding the Corsairs perceiving the Nomads as a serious threat. Could be wrong on that one.

Yes less Bounty hunters but again, common enemy does not constitute an official alliances. An official alliance can produce diplomatic consequences which the Order has already received, they can be engaged by the Outcasts because they are openly allying themselves with the Corsairs.

Waste of resources? They would probably lose more doing the above 2 things on their own.
Order isnt in full scale war with Outcasts. Dont think anybody asks for that. But you wont see an alliance with Outcasts because of their views with the nomads. I think outcasts are allowed to ally themselves with nomads in pvp fights.

Outcast aren't "allying" themselves with the Nomads but merely targeting a common enemy. Again, see reference Corsairs and the Order attacking Bounty Hunters. Could work the same way.

The Corsairs are a selfish group of pirates who only think off themselves this is not a biased view but a Role-Play one. They are pirates, says it all really?

Disco is based on vanilla. Its not a BSG or Startrek mod, its based in the Freelancer universe, very closely.

Yep its based off Vanilla, still does NOT justify the stuff that happened in the time/era of vanilla Freelancer to still be marked as valid, now as in the time of version 4.85. Also, when did I even begin talking about BSG and Startrek?

I still think all my arguments are valid. If you find them invalid please show me where Im wrong.

I have already countered your arguments with my own, that is my answer to your statement.

Now to answer your question:

What would either side gain when beraking the allaince?
NOthing,...

Thats why its in place and makes sense.

Well, the Order gain nothing. The Corsairs saves resources and pilots. Already said that. An alliance is only efficient if both parties gain a benefit. An alliance is NOT efficient if only one said gain benefit, or only one said gain the major benefit (this is the case of this alliance, Corsair gets some benefits, but nothing worth throwing away their resources for.)

If you say one argument is rp and one is oorp... I dont actually agree. If you say he is lobbying for it out of own reasons, I would suggest you are probable doing the same.

I have every right to assume some arguments are Role-Play oriented and some are not, makes sense if treated case-by-case. Of course I'm lobbying, that is the point of arguing. Everyone in Discovery is biased don't even begin there...

And their is an oorp argument that should count:
Server ballance. Corsaires dont have as many allies as Outcasts, and fewer people play as corsairs. The Corsaires would totally get their asses kicked all the time if they werent allied to Order. There would be no fun in that.

This one I agree with you, the Corsairs are having trouble with alliances and their main enemy, the Outcast have too many. Hopefully this can be fixed but I don't believe it is with the current alliance set-up for them.