I only have one CSV on the GC server, but I'm a brand new admin on the Discovery USA server. I've been studying the IDS in the new update and I know many people have posted about issues but I wanted to list the things I've seen.
Generic IDs
I personally believe that if a Freelancer, Mercenary, or Smuggler are using a ship that is mainly unlawful, they should not be able to land on lawful bases. The Smuggler ID already says this for the Pirate Train, but most of the Borderworld combat ships are used by unlawful factions and should not be landing on lawful bases.
Slaver ID
This is the only generic ID I can find that DOESN'T say Civilian and Borderworld only. I think it should be limited also.
Blood Dragon ID, Bundschuh ID, Farmers Alliance ID, Gaian ID, GC ID, LWB ID, Lane Hacker ID, Liberty Rogue ID, Molly ID, Unioner ID
These IDs were changed to only allow up to a 3800 cargo. The Smuggler ID and Pirate ID both allow for up 3800 EXCEPT for the Pirate Train. The Gallic Brigands ID, Maquis ID, and Unione Corse ID all allow for up to 3800 EXCEPT for the I'Lane.
I recommend we change the other unlawful IDs so they can use the Pirate Train. Its sold on Molly, Rogue, Junker and Zoner bases. It seems strange that the generic IDs can use it, but the specific ones can't, and I would like to see less generic IDs. At least the Mollys and Rogues should be able to since its sold at their bases.
Corsair ID
The Corsair ID and Corsair Gaurd ID were changed so that Corsairs to remove the destroy any unallied ship in Gamma. The Outcast ID, Outcast Guard ID and Blood Dragon Guard ID still have these statements. The Outcast ID reads as follows:
Can destroy on sight any ships carrying a non-allied ID within the Omicron Alpha and Beta systems.
I think the same thing for Corsairs should be added back for Gamma or those statements removed for Blood Dragons and Outcasts to keep it fair.
Bretonia Privateer ID says cannot use any transports with more than 3,800 cargo, but the Shire is listed in the allowed ships. Would recommend that "except the Shire" be added
Bundschuh Guard ID, LWB Guard ID, Lane Hacker Guard ID, Liberty Police Guard ID, Rheinland Federal Police Guard ID say cannot use transports with more than 3,800 cargo but transports are not listed in the allowed ships
Zoner Guard ID should add the Aomori Base which is GMG in Honshu, its the only Zoner allied base in a lawful house system.
