Terrorist ID: Is it even needed?

[AJBeast]

Yes.

Do you know how many times a pirate has encountered a trader, and the trader starts rule lawyering or using some other excuse to get out of having his money or cargo taken? Traders, most of all, are far too 'smug' in their little transports. Most traders I see, on any of my characters, give no effort to RP their way out of a situation, it's either run, shoot back, or start mouthing off that "you cant pirate me! iz against rulez!"

These people need to understand that the rules are not always going to protect them - and it isnt just limited to traders (though, they're by far the worst group when it comes to this behavior). Sometimes, the best way to get someone to snap to the realization that the only way out of a situation is to -roleplay- is to kill them without mercy.

People shouldnt be flying through space mouthing off at everyone they meet, they should be constantly on edge and aware that the next breath might be their last, and the only way to avoid it is through proper RP. Sometimes, that's not going to work either, but it usually does. My junker has run into phantoms and such multiple times while trading, and just as if they were pirates I always play to their tune. I may not give in, I -never- give up my money or cargo, but if you connect with the other player's RP, they're less likely to blow you up. Only recently has that approach stopped working, and I've started having to sacrafice my trading partners as bait while I run away =P

At any rate, my point is that players here are too comfortable, and the phantoms/wilde/keepers/terrorists exist to disrupt that comfort and incite a little fear and anger for the general good of the server.

So, basically, what you are saying is that we need to break our own rules to uphold their general idea? Sorry to say, but I don't believe such strategy works.

Also, what it seems to me that you are saying is that those not wanting to roleplay are not afraid enough rather than those than do. That is what the server rules are for. People who don't roleplay get the boot, simple as that. We don't need to add stuff to our universe ( "stuff" which, in my opinion, does more harm than good) to attempt to cover for something for which there are already rules for.

Well alright, I will give it a try but I don't own a Terrorist ID char myself however so I will go by logic.

Lets say you have a Terrorist ID character who is a psycho-maniac guy and has a rather sadistic behavior.

Some times this character enjoys demanding the most weirdest kinds of things such as human body-parts and sometimes he just enjoys watching things burn.

Although this character might state this in a confrontation with another character does not mean he demands something. You see he could just as easily kill the guy, in order to watch his vessel burn. Probable situation to be honest.

But let's talk about this whole "demand" thing you are going on with. I mean, just because a Terrorist ID'ed character has demands dosen't mean the ID should be thrown away. I see the point you are trying to get across here is that you can simply do the same things with a Pirate ID. But if you are a Pirate, usually you are after some kind of money or cargo. If you are planning on a larger plot regarding mass-murdering, psycho personality coupled with more rare types of needs where you most likely just go out and kill stuff in order to emphasize your character, well I guess that's when the Terrorist ID comes in.

Your question as a whole is really hard to answer, because as I said, it depends on the character in question. Perhaps try to ask someone who has a Terrorist Character.

Ok, there is a situation. Now tell me this, do you think that such a character is beneficial to our roleplay universe? A person that merely wants to see everything burn. Because I don't think it is, not at all. We do not allow people to roleplay mutes or autistics or really, any sort of character that is unable to communicate for the simple fact that they do not provide any benefit to the roleplay universe but we are allowing things like the Terrorist ID.

Also, the ID's are nothing but a canvas. It is up to you to decide what you want within it. Discussing whether "Pirates should do this" is utterly futile because we aren't technically talking about pirates, we are talking about people with the restrictions imposed by our Pirate ID.