Quote:The second is called "Denied Requests", it is unlocked, visible and free for people to post in, and as the name suggests contains denied requests.
Making denied requests is to call popularity contest and/or flaming request. What purpose would it serve if request is denied anyway and no way to revert it? It's end of the road.
Either way I don't like the proposed variant. Keep it all locked, optionally visible if needed, otherwise it's just call for trolling, public condemnation and all assorted nastiness this forum is quite popular about.
For constructive criticism I find PMs more appropriate, person-to-person without public getting in a way or catering posts for public opinion and, most commonly, trying to persuade public to support or not this or that. If a person has a problem posting constructive criticism in PM I suspect that person is not interested in providing honest and constructive opinion in the first place, instead motivated by something else and not good intentions.
