Capital Ship Realism

[EisenSeele]

I am not angry. Well, if you are not going to get them to use the rules to solve situations of abuse, then stop complaining. Quite simple really.

Rules are but another tool to add gameplay mechanics. It is a legitimate tool to fill in where the game code's limitations restrict mechanic implimentation.

I am not emotional, but eh, feel free to keep stating that I am. The problem exists in people not presenting sufficient evidence. Not the rules. Therefore the rules do not need to be fixed. The people do.

So your argument is 'everyone but me is broken, therefore there is no problem.' This is not a legitimate insight.

You tried to flip it around on me, with the "your biased" card, and failed.

The only time a capital ship has hit me, was either when I was already in combat, where an LSC main gun hit me, and killed me, or the Isis. However, the Isis did not bind me to combat. If I get hit by capital ship weapons, I am doing it wrong.

Perhaps you're good, or the guys you went up against aren't. The problem exists and is wide spread in other people - so congrats on your skills, let's fix it for everyone else who isn't exactly the red baron.

Plausible and tangible situations. The fighter should not be holding it's own against a cruiser. It should be fleeing. Eh

There shouldn't be a situation where a capital ship interdicts a small fighter period - this is part of the problem which this proposal addresses.

No, it need not dodge fire, or die, it can choose to flee from combat too.

A fighter that is not dodging against cruiser fire is dead; a cruiser that is not dodging fighter fire has an itch to scratch on an undented shield - unless the cruiser pilot is either stupid, blind, or both - the fighter is either dead or in a stalemate. Choosing to flee means death - pvp death.

They are both statement which talk about the vanilla FL aspects, due to how the game was built. No fallacy present.

A must be B. C is like A. Therefore C must be B - this is a syllogism which is a logical fallacy.

Any thread on capital ships automatically involves all other ships, since capital ships interact with everything. Everything is inter-related.

Except, the purpose of this thread is to exclusively address this proposal. You seem rather intent to 'lol no' it and put in another completely different proposal instead - if it contributes insights into this proposal, it is welcome. If it does not concern this proposal, it is not - at least on this thread.

---

FEEDBACK