Liberty Navy [LN] Feedback Thread

[Samuel Zanders]

Honestly, you claim to be trying to tighten up relationship with indy LN, yet you completely disregard valid proof that one of your members was talking down to an indy?

No, he was not talking down to LNS-BlackSteel

Black Steel had provoked Tia Whitehall PRIOR TO THE SCREENSHOTTED CONVERSATION by firing at her and then kept pushing her around to the point where she got angry and told him to do something constructive. Do you really believe Tia Whitehall saw the Dreadnought and went "IDIOT GO DO SOMETHING." Of course not. I have flown with Tia Whitehall a million times before, should that been the case, why didn't she act like that towards the plethora of Dreadnoughts we have encountered over the weeks? Makes no sense.

You are simply ignoring it with the argument that he didn't screen shot 100% of the interaction, and twisting it to support your member. Since you are twisting it your way in role play, I'll point out the following:

In role play, an ensign wouldn't get away with talking to the captain of a battleship like that. He'd be in the brig before he could finish taking a crap. Regardless of which division or fleet he was part of.

I'm not ignoring his argument at all, I'm answering him point by point. He didn't screen 100% then what am I supposed to do? Yell at my member based on empty words?

In Role-Play. He is a secondary fleet member. The ranks are entirely seperate. An Ensign in the Primary Fleet, just as in any other Primary Fleet of another house, can order a secondary fleet member regardless of rank. Or else an Flieger of the Rheinland Military or an Ensign of the BAF, would not be able to for example command over a RNC or HMS cruiser to stop firing at two fighters. That wouldn't be Role-Play right?

Just my 2 cents, which I know you will disregard because it doesn't suit you.

No. I don't disregard stuff that doesn't suit me, stop putting words in my mouth. Or you can find yourself out of this feedback thread. I take into account EVERYTHING, and I do EVERYTHING IN MY POWER to ensure that the right is right. In this case, I take into account what happened prior to that conversation, so I can understand the point of view from Tia Whitehall.