Rule Update: AI Generated Content

[Kauket]

im gonna use chatgpt to write all of my comms then shove it through google translate, bing translate, deep l translate then another layer of chatgpt then google translate it once more to make it seem like an authentic shizo ramble by revenant (summoning cultists)

---

[Uknown]

For me, Thank you @Petitioner for answering my questions, i keep it understood about it seriously man~

BlatantlyPeople

What percentage of a post must be AI-generated for it to be "removed"?

Asking the hard to quantify questions. What does it matter if the post is 69% AI and then 70% is too much? I believe the staff will take action if it's clearly AI.

If I describe a scene to ChatGPT and use its suggestions as creative input is that a violation?

From Haste's wording, it suggests using AI as an aiding tool is allowed.

Isn't punishing a player for using tools that help them participate … kind of a dick move

There's a difference between having AI allow or aid your participation vs having AI participate for you. The latter is why this rule is being implemented in my opinion.

Isn’t the point of RP to build immersion and fun?

Yes, by the players who play the game. Not by some service that writes for you.

---

I'm starting to see a pattern here. Either it's pushing boundaries so you know where the line is, or you didn't really read the post.

Not you again ... darn ...
I came by to look after an story and end questioning, my sister do that too and ends equally questioning some, questions she wanna to fully clarify.

---

@TheKusari
While we acknowledge your interpretation, this thread explicitly states:

"If you have any questions about this policy, please ask in this thread."

That invitation came from staff, not casual interpreters, or onlookers.

So no, I don’t see any reason why Tenshi or anyone should not ask one, ten, or even a hundred questions if that’s what it takes to avoid rule violations.
And in her case, it’s not just valid it is necessary. She already been sanctioned before, and publicly mocked by members of this very community.
Yes, we see what is said about us in all the servers from Discord
We know how gleeful some were when she was banned for a full month. (with me included)

And let’s be honest: my ban wasn’t even based on solid grounds it was issued “just to make sure we dont play in any way”

So do not come stepping in like you’re here to help when she’s asking with intent because she wants clarity.
Because when she comes to you in the past and asked with patience, ears open, and hands lowered even through tears at some point asking for guidance, hoping someone would finally explain or listen.
You? You ignored her TheKusari
You, someone she publicly supported, defended, and even praised as an admin.
You left her alone.
You dismissed her concerns.
And you failed her.
Because as a server administrator, you had the duty to give her answers.
Instead, someone else had to step in to explain what happened, while the rest of the community "this your community" continued to treat her as nothing but a punching bag.
She has every right to question staff to clarify her questionings about the new rule, because community made her so afraid of “how people will react” that now she filters everything.

No flair, no tone, just stripped-down, corrected, flattened writing, all to keep from being misunderstood.

We’ve even asked you before — when you were still in charge to put a stop to the harassment she faced.
You didn’t.

So now? Let her ask.
Let her speak.
Let her finally get the answers she was denied for too long.

This is not your place to interrupt.
Your authority is not relevant here.
You’re not staff anymore. The post clearly says to direct questions to those who are. (at least not seen in OF Discovery Staff Names, so please, don't make mess, she look for clarification or better to say "Enlightment" as she always like to trust)

This is a warning: stay out of the way when she’s trying to get answers. You have your understanding. She has hers.

Respect that, “TheKusari.”

---

✨ ⇝ Nanosinx#1541 ⇜ ✨

[Nika]

snip

It'd also be nice if you kept your personal grudges in the shape of those hilarious walls of text out of threads like that. It contributes nothing except maybe amusing your ego?

---

Peace, being the distant dream it is, comes inevitably, and goes hand in hand with justice.
Cursed be the war.

Heroes never die! @Vitoniz30 @Connor

[Nodoka Hanamura]

snip

It'd also be nice if you kept your personal grudges in the shape of those hilarious walls of text out of threads like that. It contributes nothing except maybe amusing your ego?

Good to know I'm not the only one who feels that way..

To append, I have to agree with the AI generated content restrictions. Whilst I've used AI before for brainstorming and other matters, I've grown to be more wary of it and for good reason. If you over-rely on it, it will stunt your growth in many of the aspects you could otherwise achieve through practice.

The only things AI that I have made, are Struikas and Kensington's profile pictures, and the only reason I say this, is because Honey Select 2 is absolute dog water at male characters without looking uncanny. I want to try and get DAZ or some other system and replace them outright, but for now it's what I've got. Everything else since my return last year has been AI-free. All of my writing, be it here, on BlueSky, back on the birdsite, on my videos on Youtube and elsewhere on the net, have been my words, my thoughts, not put into some AI to do the work for me, because that's not what these systems are meant for. And honestly, having used them decently before recently, they aren't all that good at it.

It's not hard to learn something new. I started making my characters with a fucking eroge game, managing to make them look semi-decent, and countless others have edited or ripped pictures online for use in the RP community, and for emblems have made them or taken from images online to transform them, like I had with Ouroboros' latest revision. And as someone who is autistic, who has ADHD, please do not use disabilities as an excuse to put out slop. If I can do it, you more likely than not can too.

It's a controversial take that I think will piss off some people very near to me, but I think extending the restrictions to include AI art and the sort as well would be wise as well. I know it sucks for some of us but honestly a lot of these AI artworks feel samey, especially the ones from all of these unofficial factions that with all due respect, burn out as fast as their logo was generated. But we managed to do just fine for god knows how long Disco has been alive without GenAI, we'll do just fine now. And if it goes into that good night for abandoning it, then well, I'll say it's in a better place than here and now.

---

[Weapon]

It is this simple.

Marceline grow up on planet Hudson and was always a More quite person always and never was interested in people not sharing the same interest her interest was always the Liberty Security Force and always wanted to be become one of them so she made her self up and went to Liberty navy to show her skills and proof that she is good in the things she is doing the Navy appriciated her work and told the Liberty Security Force they have someone good for their job the Liberty security force accepted that and want to put her in Section-41.

ACCEPTABLE, EVEN ENCOURAGED:




NOT ACCEPTABLE:

---

Recruitment | Task Force Prometheus | ICN FIRESTORM

[TheKusari]

I don't have questions, but will say that this is a long time coming. Happy it's finally addressed. I was mostly concerned with the usage of AI to generate images, but that's been taken care of too.

Got no problems on my end.

---

---

Discovery's Best Faction:  Starfliers
Second Best: Liberty Navy 46th Fleet

---

[Leon Straub]

im gonna use chatgpt to write all of my comms then shove it through google translate, bing translate, deep l translate then another layer of chatgpt then google translate it once more to make it seem like an authentic shizo ramble by revenant (summoning cultists)

[Shulsky]

I thought "Don't have AI write your RP" went without saying but I guess I was wrong. Glad to see it put into writing. Sad to see people defending it.

Personally? I long for the day when I can use the guillotine on Google Gemini's servers.

---

Operation Have Sea

[Xenon]

Thank you for adding this rule. It makes good sense.

I believe that AI writing RP for players is like playing for them lol, so what is the point of playing then
I am a non-English speaker, but I know how to speak and write English (to a certain extent lol), I am not an expert, but I can form some phrases
I use GRAMMARLY to correct my grammar, because I am no good with grammar sometimes xD

Concerning AI-generated images, I sometimes need some fast-made templates or portraits, so I generate them through AI
I hope that this is not a problem. Cheers

---

NEBULA INFORMATION BOT ☆ NEBULA DISCORD SERVER
XENON WEAPONS MARKET ☆ NEBULA GRAND PLAZA ☆ NEBULA TECHNOLOGIES
THE DISCOVERY POBCAST ☆ DISCOVERY SERVER RULES

[Soban]

All that sounds good. Yet I see a problem.
As AI will get better and harder to detect over time, how you will detect it?
Because as Godlslayer said, AI detector on text are not 100% reliable.
So how will you judge the uses of advanced AI?
I can smell VR will be filled and I'm curious how the staff will judge people writting fairly.
Right now it's easy to spot massive lore error and some gramatical and syntax pattern.
But that will become harder and harder, and I fear some honest lore mistake or really well written post will be taken as AI usage and report (some just out of spite) will be filled .

Will people need to save all their draft and concept to defend themselves like we already feel a need to reccord nearly each interraction ingame?

---