I know AC Merc made one of these a long time ago (back around when I first joined) and it dropped off the map... I digged around and got it; the only 2 people on the list that'd still make the list are Darkstar and Mon'Star. I'm proposing a new one with up-to-date badguys that would be pinned and cared for, as well as bounties placed by factions on these people (for example, RM would bounty Wesley Richter, but anyone could bounty Mon'Star).
I remember that. Only problem was (as far as I remember) people were kinda only got on it by posting it themselves, which is blowing your own trumpet a little. Perhaps we can find a way of changing that a little. And would it also be better to do a Sirius most wanted, and then one for each house?
I think people should start posting general bounties (bounties available to ALL rather then simply to mercs etc. Hired hits.). And those who accumilate the most bounty on themselves can earn their place on the Most wanted. The amount would include both the bounties collected(up to 2 months back) And those still pending. However, a means of recording this would really help. But I think this would really help out one manner of determining the most wanted. The amount DOES NOT include those posted by the Unlawfuls against Lawfuls(however lawfuls against invaders from another House does count).
A separate thread where people submit their applications for the list and where certain people review their merits would suffice, I think... bounties are a tricky business, because sometimes some people don't attack traders (who mostly put out the bounties), or they're not terribly active on that ship.