Just a little note to everyone discussing things here. Please keep it civil and on topic. Respect a player faction right, official or not to direct the roleplay development of their player faction. Not every player faction is a carbon copy of the NPC group, some deviate from the NPC mold and that is one of the things that makes player factions in Discovery so interesting. This is somewhat like a faction feedback thread, and it should be treated as such. You are welcome to leave your opinions and critiques of the faction, but this shouldn't be a place for arguments back and forth. If a person feels they are making the same point over and over, it is probably time to walk away from the thread.
Thank you for continuing this in a civil and respectful manner.
Now, related to your faction, I have changed my stance, I am against your officiality. I had faith in the leadership of this faction with Etien, I don't know what's going on inside your faction, but I extremely despise your attitude Seby, and I'm extremely confident that your attitude is not going to change at all seeing how it's been the past few months. You only accept praise, you heat at an extraordinary rate when someone bring up a point, valid or not, you'll prove the person is wrong with an attitude close to hate.
' Wrote:I see this is becoming a "NO U - NO U" discussion. So, please restrain from posting here anymore with the intention of repeating yourself over and over again, as that is bringing us nowhere.
This is indeed NO U content because you are doing what you're criticizing too.
' Wrote:You can take this to flood, or even better, message me on Skype if you have something to discuss with me. But please not here, this thread is here for feedback, both negative and positive, and what you did now is not feedback anymore for me.
Who are you to say that ? Because you are the OP you can decide who post in and who doesn't ? Sure, maybe Ryummel's posts weren't completely focused on the topic, but I've read the whole page and each post constitute feedback but you've been both staying in your corner of the room behind a "NO U" shield, how did you expect this to make any progress ?
' Wrote:Yours faithfully,
Seby
This just look like provocation towards Ryummel to me, we know who you are, it's written on the left.
Now I'm not going to quote every bit of the last page posts, but here's my thoughts about the debate :
Experimenting is good, very good, but to an extent. But what are we supposed to think if you become the official Maquis faction and you have no clear roleplay directives ? I've been interacting with you on many different sides aswell as spectating on others, and I have absolutely NO CLUE of what your faction goals are. You said you are not "pirates" but "brigands". Define what it is, clearly. Your interactions on my GRN and USI are completely opposed and what I've seen in Tau-23 is not good at all either, Chevalier has seen this behavior too it seems.
The quality of the Legion roleplay has downgraded to an absurd level aswell as the general behavior, I'm sorry to have to say it but you do not meet anymore the level of roleplay expected from an official faction and I have not seen some who had the best roleplay capabilities of the Legion for a while. This is mainly Christine, Felix, Damien, Etien.
To sum up, the leadership does not act like the leadership of an official faction, the behavior is not the one expected from an official faction. Your faction does not meet the officiality requirements.
I am against your officiality.
Edit :
' Wrote:That comment is totally unnecessary and doesn't belong here. It's not feedback. Read the comment above you in orange.
It's feedback.
' Wrote:This is somewhat like a faction feedback thread, and it should be treated as such. You are welcome to leave your opinions and critiques of the faction, but this shouldn't be a place for arguments back and forth.
+LE+ acting bad and someone telling about it IS feedback. It is supposed to make you rethink your behavior. His post is about your behavior, this part quoted from Zelot says you are welcome to leave your opinions and critiques and this is what he is doing.
' Wrote:This is somewhat like a faction feedback thread, and it should be treated as such. You are welcome to leave your opinions and critiques of the faction, but this shouldn't be a place for arguments back and forth.
Please do not edit my posts. If you post a sentence of mine, post the whole sentience, don't cut it off and add a period to make what I say look like something else.
Didn't intend to make look like such Zelot, the following was just not related to the point I brought up so I've cut it off for TL;DR reasons. I'll add it.
But seriously, we do the best we can..With what we have to work with...
And as of late I can say that the only other Gallic group coming close to / at the same level / going beyond our amount of RP and activity has to be the Council...
-"If we do not learn at least one thing a day....Our minds turn to stupor"- Kyle Sparrgrove -2005
![[Image: 9rXD1gi.png]](https://i.imgur.com/9rXD1gi.pnghttps://i.imgur.com/9rXD1gi.png)
![[Image: 13121_s.gif]](http://signavatar.com/13121_s.gif)
![[Image: 2zrfioi.png]](http://i40.tinypic.com/2zrfioi.png)
![[Image: signature2n.jpg]](http://img815.imageshack.us/img815/7042/signature2n.jpg)
![[+]](/forums/images/collapse_collapsed.png "[+]")