I think that proposition is kind of flawled. As far as I remember, Pirate ID forces certain unlawful factions to be no-dock or even hostile.
It's not flawed, i didn't say it removes the rephacks. But it gets you pretty much every NON-REPHACKED faction neutral or friendly.
I know this, I just pointed out that certain factions, for a certain reason, are rephacked when they shouldn't - at least in my opinion.
It would be nice to ask devs to provide the list which unlawful factions are not rephacked on the Pirate ID, because it is a great unknown unless you try to rephack a faction - then you are pretty surprised upon undock..