Should a recommended ship list exist?

[Akumabito]

As for the exceptions, they SHOULD be allowed on the basis of very good roleplay and admin approval.

Now tell me why.

They shouldn't be allowed

1. Out of a sense of fairness. It's fair when everyone is under the same treatment, under the same rules. When you make exceptions, where an admin can put his buddy in a better ship to pvp better, then ban someone else he doesn't like for the same thing, or a faction can fly a ship an indie can't, then you abandon the concept of being fair across the board. Your saying "I should have a pvp advantage because of who I know."

2. Because RP doesn't require it. While it's possible to justify an uber combo with RP, that makes RP less pure. Good RP can deal with flying the same ship everyone with that tag is allowed.

You didn't get it.

I got it completely. The official faction should control people who didn't join and don't want to join, but want to fly that ID.

It's a powergrab and I disagree with it.