Does RP even matter?

[CzeReptile]

Having written wall of text does not mean player is good roleplayer. He might simply have writing talents.

Roleplay is carrying out your role.

Pirate - pirating.
Greedy pirate - pirating hard.
Chatty Pirate - Chatting piracy.
etc.

I would not even call engagment notice as good roleplay if two mortal enemies are fighting.

We cannot really judge roleplay without bias, as it looks different to all of us.

What one calls 2 million demand a good roleplay, might mean he likes the fairplay.
Another person might say he would have demanded twice as much, since that would be what his pirate character's role is.

Well, definition of roleplay differs. You dont need to write textwall, all you need to know is who your character is, how we reacts, acts and behaves. Adapting from your chair without regard to your previous actions is just basic roleplaying. Tsk tsk.

---