Guy A is all happy and Guy C, D and E are having fun RPing with me, even if they don't understand how his RP works.
Problem?
You can't expect every single person you play your weird roles with to do research just so they understand your roleplay. Obviously, if someone doesn't understand the background and reasons behind you character they'll form incorrect ideas about your character and you can't prevent this unless you give every person a lesson on your roleplay before you even begin. You're also forgetting that some people actually prefer to be ignorant so they can continue to twist and look down on your roleplay.
' Wrote:Guy B, however, will go whine about it on the forums, it'll take the shape of this argument:
'x is improbable for y reason and if you disagree with me I'll tell you you're wrong because of z'
Granted some people are hard to convince and stubborn, if you can't make someone understand your roleplay then simply ignore them instead of going on war trying to argue why you're right and they're wrong. If you do this then you're only wasting your time.