The Liberty Carrier replacement poll!

[Sprolf]

I am sufficiently amused.

---

[Seth Karlo]

Well, the version I have is an older version, it IS different, but not by much... The version posted here is better (Larger windows, slightly different textures etc).

It would be nice to talk to Xing and ask what he feels, as it IS his model... all three of them... >.<

---

Signature by Sleipnir.

[Marcus Lindberg]

I would prefer Karolia's version. Its longer and larger, which would mean easier to get hit with a snac, which would be less people using the carrier, which is the way I see it because theres only something like 12 Nimitz Class Aircraft Carriers in the world, one of the worlds largest seaborne ships right now. I know we arent supposed t compare reality and FL, but considering the resources used to make such large ships, I think it would be common to not see soo many of these flying around. I just have one complaint with the Karolia's model, its that it has too many small details, which aren't eye candy really. I don't know if its possible to make the model a bit simpler at this point, but my vote goes to Karolia's version.

[schlurbi]

Both are not perfect, but currently smaller one looks better. It isn't huge as the dark Carrier and this one also uses the ****ty dark Texture as the current Carrier has.

---

"Who is it doing this synthetic type of alpha beta psychedelic funkin'?"

[Seth Karlo]

Well, I can offer to retexture it for him...

---

Signature by Sleipnir.

[schlurbi]

Well it is not only the Texture. I also dislike that the Center is kind of overdone. Sure Details are nice, but that is just too much. Looks almost messy. I also dislike that the Liberty Sign is 3D as well, I prefer it being painted or put into the Inside, not Outside.

---

"Who is it doing this synthetic type of alpha beta psychedelic funkin'?"

[Cosmos]

Meh..Rheinland, Bretonia and Kusari need more ships..Not the cesspit of DiscoGC(Be honest folks, There's like 50 Lulwuts in sys chat a day)

Liberty has many capitals, whereas the other 3 factions are lacking...Alot.

Moar ships for the factions that need them! (Xeno's being First)

---

[22:50:33] ☆ҳ̸̲Ҳ̸ҳEternal†Nightmareҳ̸̲Ҳ̸ҳ☆(illi): i cyber with leather torps (smoking)

[Seth Karlo]

Ok, I've now got both models, and here are some pictures of them side by side (All are about 4000x3000 resolution)

http://www.alphaomega.x10hosting.com/ima...riers1.jpg

http://www.alphaomega.x10hosting.com/ima...riers2.jpg

http://www.alphaomega.x10hosting.com/ima...riers3.jpg

http://www.alphaomega.x10hosting.com/ima...riers4.jpg

http://www.alphaomega.x10hosting.com/ima...riers5.jpg

http://www.alphaomega.x10hosting.com/ima...riers6.jpg

I personally prefer the second one... (not the one I originally submitted). My reasons:

-More space for hardpoints.
-It's sleeker and looks like an upgraded Dread, instead of a modified one.
-It hasn't a big hole in the middle of it.

It does need some retexturing, I had to edit the texture files in 3ds MAX in order to see them (They were tuned extremely light).

-Seth

---

Signature by Sleipnir.

[Luis]

Korolia + Xing = Yue Fi.

Done and Said to public.

Both models are good in terms of details (in my opinion, yet - it can do far much better than that) - The textures it has seems to simple and yet, poorly done - like his/her previous she/he has made.

I am no longer amused with these models at any extent.

My vote is neither. Someone has to come up with a better quality. Yet, submit this as a temporary replacement of the current Carrier we have.

[mjolnir]

I like the second one (dread with a hole), the first one just has too many things here and there.

Problem with the second one is that from front/back it's very much same size as LN Dread and it's not really bigger from top/bottom either.

So it would most likely get medium powerplant instead of current big one.. and then it would be kind of pointless for LN to have 2 rather similar ships?

---

Igiss says: Martin, you give them a finger, they bite off your arm.