The Liberty Carrier replacement poll!

[Eppy]

I don't like either model. I think the design of the current Lib Carrier is fine; the model just needs some serious quality improvements.

---

Quick comment - we thought that Panzer was the Leader, Swift. -Agmen

Which Dreadnought was that?

One of your nine.

[Durandal]

I'm with Turkish and Eppy on this one. The current carrier is a much more original design than just lib dread kitbashes...

Problem is that nobody can be arsed to do an HQ version, so it'll either be something completely new or not.

[Seth Karlo]

You make a fair point Mjolnir.

Looks like we might need a completely new one... I might attempt it at some point in the future. Too busy trying to figure out Sur Splicing for now.

-Seth

---

Signature by Sleipnir.

[Doom]

while i like both models. What i dont like is texture job on either one....model with such detail modeled needs precise texturing...

[Luis]

while i like both models. What i dont like is texture job on either one....model with such detail modeled needs precise texturing...

Agreed.

Both models are good yet, the textures are horrid.

[Korolia]

If I changed my name, it obviously is so people quit referencing me to my old name. Something it seems, very few can understand.

I also dont really care of the result out of this poll. It is pretty much the opinion of every hating me that my models will never be up to whatever their amazing standards could be.

I just make these models, and leave them be. Spit on them or admire them as much as you like, at that point Im pretty much done with the drama that spawns in the dev section... so grab your flamethrower and have fun with your hate mails.

---

There is no bathroom!

[Cray]

Kudos to you Korolia, overlook the drama and return to the basics when this game was a enjoyable bliss to play.
By the way I miss seeing your Coalition character around, fun times were had.

---

"Judge me if you want, we're all going to die eventually. I for one intend to deserve it."

[Death.RunningVerminator]

Xing's looks more like a Dread.. So.. I'll have to go with Korolias's model. Great work guys.

Also:

I don't like either model. I think the design of the current Lib Carrier is fine; the model just needs some serious quality improvements.

[Jeremy Hunter]

I like Korolia's, the second doesnt look...carrier-ish?

And the current model is too...wide...

---

May you ever walk in the Light, Shizune.

[Oldum]

Ok, I've now got both models, and here are some pictures of them side by side (All are about 4000x3000 resolution)

http://www.alphaomega.x10hosting.com/ima...riers1.jpg

http://www.alphaomega.x10hosting.com/ima...riers2.jpg

http://www.alphaomega.x10hosting.com/ima...riers3.jpg

http://www.alphaomega.x10hosting.com/ima...riers4.jpg

http://www.alphaomega.x10hosting.com/ima...riers5.jpg

http://www.alphaomega.x10hosting.com/ima...riers6.jpg

I personally prefer the second one... (not the one I originally submitted). My reasons:

-More space for hardpoints.
-It's sleeker and looks like an upgraded Dread, instead of a modified one.
-It hasn't a big hole in the middle of it.

It does need some retexturing, I had to edit the texture files in 3ds MAX in order to see them (They were tuned extremely light).

-Seth

I'd like to add something to this, since we already know how their size is compared to each other, but I've been thinking about how they look compared to current liberty warships. So I did these ..

http://i630.photobucket.com/albums/uu23/ol...00-33-27-22.png

http://i630.photobucket.com/albums/uu23/ol...00-33-45-46.png

http://i630.photobucket.com/albums/uu23/ol...00-33-46-45.png

http://i630.photobucket.com/albums/uu23/ol...00-33-54-74.png

I think the models are fine as they are, although the one came out of Korolia's hands could be move clear to the eye with a different texture ... like many others said before me.

Still, I'd go for Korolia's carrier model, it looks more advanced and different from the current dread/carrier ... which is the point in it.

---

| Faction Information || Recruitment || Feedback || Internal Communications || Nightmare on Shetland |
| The Mindoro Massacre |